A light haze hangs in the air when, after almost two hours of discussion in Leipzig’s east, all the known and unknown points about the planned Cannabis Act (CanG) have once again been exchanged. In the pelting rain, a few attendees of the panel discussion stand huddled together outside the door of a corner building on Neustädter Markt and risk a first taste of the promised freedom under the eyes of the local police leadership. A distinctive smell drifts into the hall of the Pöge-Haus. Not legal, but tolerated within unclear limits – a feeling that many consumers surely know only too well.
The SPD had issued the invitation to Leipzig’s east to talk about “Green Light for Cannabis.” The organizers had probably hoped for a better mood when they were preparing the event. According to the original schedule, the planned Cannabis Act (CanG) was supposed to be passed by the Bundestag this very week, on November 16, 2023. But after a brief announcement on Friday about yet another delay, that hope was abruptly dashed. Not even the high-profile panel on Monday evening could change that. Alongside the SPD members of the Bundestag Carmen Wegge and Holger Mann, Georg Wurth, managing director of the DHV (German Hemp Association), was also present. On the other side sat the head of the Leipzig Police Directorate, René Demmler, and Uwe Killisch, specialist officer at Aktion Jugendschutz Sachsen (a Saxon organization for the protection of minors).
Three Steps to Legalization
Carmen Wegge, who has been on the road for months as the face of the SPD’s legalization effort, once again set out the key points of the draft so far: prohibition does not work, consumption figures are rising, a 100% black market with organized crime and dangerous adulterants, no quality control and the risk of prosecution for consumers make a new approach to dealing with cannabis necessary. The “traffic light” coalition wants to take a path to legalization that is secure under European law and to pass the law in the Bundestag before the end of this year. The last week of sittings, between December 11 and 15, is earmarked for this. Decriminalization is important as a first step, she said, in order “to make legal routes possible for consumers,” so that consumers would then no longer have to rely on “some kind of crap” from the black market. This is then to be followed by the so-called pillar 2, under which specialist shops with commercial sales are to be operated in model regions, accompanied by scientific research. In a third step, European law is to be changed in order to achieve full legalization.
The first means to this end, she said, is the EU Parliament, by passing a corresponding law there. But since elections are coming up soon in Strasbourg, the majorities for a European legalization are uncertain. Wegge sees problems in implementing the extensive monitoring requirements. Many of the fine-grained rules, she said, are difficult or even impossible for the police to check. However, the Bundestag is continuing to work on solutions and simplifications. The lawyer’s heart, meanwhile, beats for the cultivation clubs, which she sees as lying beyond European law in a gray area of personal use. There, alongside private cultivation, legal supply is to be tried out with a “rather socialist solution.” Only in pillar 2 would the revenue from commercial sales then come, and with it taxes that are to flow into prevention.
Perplexity
René Demmler, head of the Leipzig Police Directorate, sees little merit in the planned law. He does acknowledge that legalization will be good for a certain number of people. However, he has doubts about how many consumers will abide by the law under the planned model and whether the black market will shrink to any appreciable extent. He said he could understand, for legal reasons, the intermediate step of a “legalization light,” but from the police perspective he sees no sensible means of implementing it: “We are somewhat at a loss as to how we are supposed to enforce the law.” Monitoring cultivation sites, quantity limits and minimum distances will be very difficult for the police, he said: “I believe that many goals will not be achieved, other than that consumption is made possible.” In addition, cannabis accounts for only about 3% of all investigative work in the police directorate. Consumption offenses are manageable, he said, but the effort of prosecuting illegal trade would remain. He therefore cannot see any appreciable relief for police work and asks why relieving the police has to be an argument for legalization at all.
Prevention
Uwe Killisch of Aktion Jugendschutz Sachsen is not really able to welcome legalization either and notes that it would bring additional risks for children and adolescents. His argument: “If the state allows it, then it’s not so bad.” The same would be the case with alcohol and nicotine. So there is no need, he said, for an additional substance that poses a further danger. In addition, he sees problems with the federal government’s prevention campaign, the role of the prevention officers in the cultivation clubs is unclear, he said, and moreover there is no guarantee of protection in the case of home cultivation. For him, the question of personal responsibility is also overstretched, since “experience with children and adolescents shows that this does not work with alcohol and tobacco.” With adolescents, he said, personal responsibility is a difficult matter. In his opinion, the same applies to certain adults whose capacity for responsibility is likewise limited by consumption. His demand: the protection of children and minors needs more money and support. Even without cannabis legalization.
Civil Rights
For Georg Wurth, by contrast, developments are heading in the right direction, but there is still a long way to go. Prohibition has achieved nothing, he said. Consumption figures are rising even though Germany is one of the most repressive states in all of Europe. The prosecution that takes place despite the small-quantity rule is particularly unjust, he said, which makes legalization a civil rights issue as well. There are no medical reasons why cannabis would have to be banned. On the contrary: “The plant itself is not psychoactive in its raw state, and the black market has only negative consequences for consumers. Consumer protection is simply not possible under illegality.” Overall, he considers the law too repressive and criticizes the excessive threats of punishment. Wurth also considers the ban on consumption in the clubs unrealistic. The problems with European law have moreover led the CanG to treat the cultivation clubs in a “downright paranoid” way, he said. Anything that looks like commerce is therefore hemmed in excessively.
A Discussion with Strong Opinions
There is also argument about the experience following legalization in Canada, the question of what percentage decline in the black market constitutes a success, uncertainties about limits in road traffic and the practical challenges of successful home cultivation. On the subject of driver’s licenses and limits in road traffic, meanwhile, the ball is still in the Ministry of Transport’s court. There is now a new commission there that is to set a new limit for cannabis in the course of the first quarter of 2024. Several Cannabis Social Clubs were also among the guests and took part in the discussion with strong opinions. Despite several follow-up questions, details on quantity limits, cultivation and definitions in the law remain unresolved. Among them the question of whether the quantity limit is measured in the dry or wet state, how this works out in practice for people who cultivate, and which parts of the plant exactly are counted toward which quantity limits, and how.
Much Smoke About Nothing?
What remains after yet another round of discussion on the subject? Carmen Wegge has learned a lot about cultivation in recent months, but cannot imagine doing it herself. Georg Wurth feels triggered by misquoted study results. The police have nothing against cannabis as long as people abide by the law, and the protection of children and minors is underfunded. That may not be much that is new. But just as with the CanG, here too a little is still better than nothing at all.
Image sources
- Grafik von Handschellen: Grafik von Clker-Free-Vector-Images auf Pixabay
- Foto von Hanfblatt in schwarz-weiß: Foto von Kym MacKinnon auf Unsplash


